Al is joined by Nuno, Drexy and Adam to ask whether early access has become the real launch for strategy games, and whether 1.0 releases that are broken or empty should have carried an early access tag. They look at Steam’s rules, refunds, AI flooding the store and why big studios avoid the label.
https://criticalmovespodcast.com/listen
This episode takes up a trend Al has noticed: strategy games now seem either to launch in early access or to launch at 1.0 in a state that would once have earned that label. The hosts discuss Ben Angel’s criticism of Imperator: Rome from episode 73, Civilization 7, EU5, Distant Worlds 2 and City Skylines 2, and compare them with recent releases that handled early access well, including Menace, Task Force Admiral and Xenonauts 2. They question whether Valve enforces enough, whether refund windows suit unfinished games, whether early access buyers are being used as paid testers, and why AAA studios avoid the tag. They end with one change each and agree that early access is broken, abused and hard to fix.
Critical Moves Podcast: Episode 108 Show Notes
Episode Title: The Early Accessification of Strategy Games
Hosts: Al, Nuno, Drexy, Adam
Episode Length: ~53 minutes
Episode Summary
Al asks whether early access has become the default launch for strategy games, and whether many full releases are really early access titles without the label. The hosts consider the expectations now placed on early access, whether 1.0 still means anything, how Steam’s tools and weaknesses affect the system, and why developers and publishers choose the route they do. Along the way they cover AI generated games clogging Steam, refund windows, paid beta testing and Civilization 7. Each host ends with one proposed change, and the group agrees that early access is abused and that nobody knows how to fix it.
The Premise: Everything Is Early Access Now
Al opens by observing that strategy games seem either to release into early access or to arrive at 1.0 so broken that they should have been early access. He frames the episode as a question about whether early access is the honest way to release, and whether a 1.0 launch that is unfinished is the real offence.
Do AAA Studios Use Early Access?
The hosts note that AAA studios rarely use early access, and debate whether Heroes of Might and Magic: Olden Era counts as AAA given that Ubisoft passed it on to Hooded Horse. They raise No Man’s Sky as a big game that arguably should have been early access, and wonder what will happen with the Heroes of Might and Magic III remake.
Imperator: Rome and Ben Angel
Al recalls that the idea came from Dr Ben Angel in episode 73, who felt offended when he bought Imperator: Rome and found it empty, calling it a vehicle for DLC. The hosts agree that a game released in that condition arguably should have carried an early access tag, since the point of early access is to release something, gather feedback and build towards a complete game.
Paradox, Civilization 7 and Distant Worlds 2
Drexy points to Victoria 3, EU5 and Civilization 7 as games people say will be good in a few years, asking why they were not early access. He argues that Distant Worlds 2 would have been better received in early access, since players would have been more willing to give it a second chance, and notes that Matrix and Slitherine have a policy against early access.
Is Early Access Armour Against Criticism?
Al asks whether early access is used to deflect criticism. The others note that a developer must choose the early access tag at release and cannot adopt it after bad reviews, so any such protection has to be planned in advance. They also note that developers who apologise to the community after a poor early access launch often must have known the state of the game, and Al adds that Amplitude’s CEO has said that arriving in early access with an unfinished game will now get you crushed.
Is 1.0 Still a Milestone?
The hosts agree that early access has effectively become the launch and 1.0 is often just another point in a development cycle. Nuno argues that the bar has been raised in a good way, helped by years of players being burned by early access games that ran out of money, and that players now expect an early access game to be close to finished.
Good Examples from 2026
Nuno lists 2026 releases that either handled early access well or released finished and were strong: Menace, Task Force Admiral, Star Wars Zero Company, Vulture, Burden of Command’s Three Nations DLC, Heroes of Might and Magic: Olden Era and Xenonauts 2 reaching 1.0. He suggests the picture is a mix of good games in both camps. Al notes the team had concerns about Menace’s early access content before playing, but that it was handled well.
Does 1.0 Mean Anything?
Al wonders whether a 1.0 launch has lost its meaning and notes that early access releases often get only one chance to land. Nuno suggests that 1.0 matters mainly where a game depends on a particular component, such as multiplayer or single player, and the hosts agree that developers rarely face consequences for failing to reach it.
Long Stays in Early Access and Steam’s Stale Notice
Drexy says Endless Legend 2 saw a large spike when it reached 1.0, comparing it with Xenonauts 2, which had been in early access for around four years. The hosts say some players wait for 1.0 and others buy in simply to support a developer. They also note that Steam now flags early access games with no update for twelve months, which has occasionally pushed developers to return and patch.
Is Early Access Used as Intended?
Al asks two questions: whether early access is being used in the spirit it was designed for, and whether developers who fail to leave early access should face consequences. Drexy says it has been abused heavily, while Adam argues that Steam provides more tools, such as refunds and early access notices, than consoles, which offer none, so things would be worse without it. The hosts recall that early access was meant to replace Greenlight and help indie developers, bringing in people from crowdfunding platforms.
AI Slop and a Store Hard to Browse
Nuno worries that if poor quality AI generated games can be excused with early access, an already messy Steam storefront will become impossible to browse. He misses the more curated Steam of the early 2010s. One host says they receive large numbers of AI generated game emails daily, and that legitimate developers are waiting for approval behind a backlog.
Bringing Back Greenlight
Drexy argues that Valve should bring Greenlight back so developers must present a plan and the community can judge whether a game belongs on Steam, rather than allowing anything that looks good because of AI.
Should Valve Hold the Profits Until 1.0?
Drexy suggests Valve could hold profits until a game reaches 1.0. Al and others reply that this defeats the point, since indie developers use early access to fund development, and those who needed funds would simply release at 1.0 unfinished. The hosts consider holding back a smaller share, such as 30 per cent, but do not settle the question.
Do Early Access Games Get Kinder Reviews?
The hosts discuss whether players forgive an unfinished early access game. Nuno says it depends on the game, with systems driven strategy games being easier to enjoy early than story driven ones, and that players can tell good from bad quickly. Al cites Stormgate, whose CEO has said it launched undercooked and that the team overhyped and underdelivered, as an example of a game that was not forgiven for being in early access.
What Developers Must Tell Players
Adam says developers should tell players how unfinished a game is and that players are entitled to review it as unfinished. Drexy and Al counter that Valve does not enforce meaningful disclosure, so developers can write whatever they like in the early access FAQ, including release dates that may never be met, and that some games are barely a tech demo.
Refund Windows and Frontloading
The hosts note that Steam applies the same two hour refund window to early access and full games, and that developers can frontload tutorials or content to push players past it. Some suggest a longer window for early access, perhaps five hours, while Al worries that a longer window would simply be abused. Adam adds that a player who is told what will be in the finished game and does not get it has a case for a refund.
Are Early Access Buyers Paid Beta Testers?
Al asks whether studios with deep pockets, such as Creative Assembly, are using early access to outsource testing. Nuno, a software developer, says even the best paid QA team finds only a fraction of what players find, and others note that different PC hardware makes full testing impossible. Drexy adds that many studios know a game is not ready but release anyway under publisher or quarterly pressure.
Civilization 7 as Early Access in Disguise
Drexy argues that Civilization 7 was effectively early access, and that Firaxis and Take-Two knew it was not ready and took the money before fixing it. The others note that Take-Two’s chief executive said the game met expectations, and that large studios are unlikely to use the early access label because it signals weakness or risk.
Paradox Sequels and City Skylines 2
Adam argues that a sequel in development for five years cannot easily match a predecessor with fifteen years of updates, citing Paradox, while Civilization 6 had fewer feature expansions and so was easier to follow. Al cites City Skylines 2 as an early access game without the tag, noting that Paradox warned fans before release, that its first DLC reached 4 per cent positive on Steam, and that the studio apologised and refunded buyers.
The Real Sin
Al argues that the true offence is releasing an unfinished game as a 1.0 and leaving out the early access label, since players can forgive an early access title that is unfinished by design. He adds that patch culture and DLC have normalised this, and that some players now buy games expecting them to be good in two or five years.
Why AAA Studios Avoid the Label
One host reports that an AI assistant told them AAA studios avoid early access because people are less likely to buy in early access, and because bad early access reviews follow the game to 1.0. Adam adds that developer bonuses may be tied to review scores, and that critics’ scores rarely change after release while Steam user scores do. Drexy argues that early access games still deserve criticism, because players are being asked to pay.
One Change Each
Drexy asks each host for one simple change. Suggestions include a mandatory roadmap with timelines, a confirmed 1.0 release date, and a refund route where a developer fails to deliver what was promised. Al wonders about enforcement, and the hosts discuss an investment style warning on Steam, banning developers who abuse early access, and the example of the Stardrive developer who boasted about his sales instead of fixing the game.
Does Withholding Funds Defeat the Point?
Al repeats the case against holding funds until 1.0: the developers early access is meant to help would not use it. The hosts agree that early access is broken, abused and rarely used as intended, and that they do not know how to fix it.
Contact & Links
About | Contact | Meet the Team | Get Involved | Forum | Episodes
Discord | Reddit | Twitter / X | Facebook
Instagram | Twitch | Steam Group | Steam Curator
YouTube | Spotify | Apple | Amazon
Email: [email protected]
Episode Verdict
This is a spirited discussion that wisely treats 1.0 releases without the label as a bigger problem than early access itself, a distinction that gives the episode a clear thesis. The City Skylines 2 and Civilization 7 examples ground the argument well, and Nuno’s list of 2026 releases is a useful reminder that early access can work when done honestly. The proposed fixes, from held back funds to longer refund windows, are all challenged by someone in the room, which keeps the conversation honest and explains why it ends without a solution. Some of the claims about why AAA studios avoid early access rest on speculation, but the hosts present them as opinion and the argument holds up.
Discover more from Critical Moves
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


