A Strategy Gaming Podcast

About Critical Moves

Al, Jack, and Adam tackle Menace – Hooded Horse’s most anticipated turn-based tactics game from the Battle Brothers team – recorded just 10 days before early access launch, revealing frustrations with overwhelming complexity, questionable demo design, and an unprecedented information blackout that raises uncomfortable questions about whether beloved indie publishers deserve the same scrutiny as AAA studios. https://criticalmovespodcast.com/listen This episode provides an honest assessment of Menace’s strengths and significant concerns, with hosts who genuinely enjoyed the tactical combat nevertheless questioning whether Overhype Studios and Hooded Horse are exploiting community goodwill to obscure an incomplete early access release. The conversation dissects the demo’s steep learning curve without tutorials, complex action point systems managing deployment, suppression, and cover mechanics, and extensive squad customization that paradoxically lacks meaningful specialization forcing strategic choices. The hosts explore comparisons to Battle Brothers, debate whether overwhelming information...
The Critical Moves team delivers their first internal retrospective, examining their breakthrough year through favourite guest interviews, debating whether they qualify as journalists, and confronting the misleading “gaming industry in decline” narrative while explaining why their independence from publishers enables brutal honesty about strategy games. https://criticalmovespodcast.com/listen This episode provides unfiltered team reflections on Critical Moves’ first full year, where Jack and Adam discuss how joining the podcast became career highlights while Al confronts the stress of managing a multinational volunteer team. The hosts dissect the false narrative that gaming is...
Our strategy gaming veterans review 2025’s releases and discover that DLCs and definitive editions outperformed new titles, with picks including a 21-year-old RTS remaster, expansions for niche 4X games, and grand strategy economic overhauls—revealing a year where passion projects trumped major studio releases. https://criticalmovespodcast.com/listen This episode provides an unfiltered assessment of strategy gaming’s 2025 output, where established titles and their expansions delivered better experiences than new releases. The hosts discuss Spell Force Conquest of Eo’s sustained development despite modest sales, Victoria 3’s economy-transforming Charter of Commerce DLC, and Dawn of...
Al and Tim examine Creative Assembly’s December announcements of Medieval 3 and Total War Warhammer 40K, exploring whether the new Warcore engine justifies 16 years of waiting, why the studio’s deafening silence on player-controlled space combat suggests auto-resolve fleet battles rather than Battlefleet Gothic-style naval warfare, and whether simultaneous PC and console release will compromise the complexity that defines Total War’s identity, while questioning if Creative Assembly can regain community trust after Warhammer 3’s disastrous AI updates and whether their established DLC monetization strategy will exploit Warhammer 40K’s vast factional...
Al, Adam, and Tim examine the city builder genre’s evolution from SimCity’s 1989 origins through City Skylines’ dominance to the controversial developer change for City Skylines 2, exploring why Paradox removed Colossal Order from development after three years of attempted fixes, whether the game’s failure stemmed from rushed release pressure or fundamental design problems, and how different city builder subgenres—from Anno’s island logistics to Banished’s survival mechanics—serve distinct player preferences between aesthetic builders and optimization enthusiasts. https://criticalmovespodcast.com/listen This episode delivers comprehensive analysis of city builder gaming’s current state through examination...
block

Critical Moves Podcast Trailer

AL

CRITICAL MOVES FOUNDER

NUNO

CRITICAL MOVES FOUNDER

JOSEPH

CRITICAL MOVES HOST

TIMOTHY

CRITICAL MOVES HOST

ADAM

CRITICAL MOVES HOST

JACK

CRITICAL MOVES HOST / ASSISTANT EDITOR