Al, Jack, and Adam tackle Menace – Hooded Horse’s most anticipated turn-based tactics game from the Battle Brothers team – recorded just 10 days before early access launch, revealing frustrations with overwhelming complexity, questionable demo design, and an unprecedented information blackout that raises uncomfortable questions about whether beloved indie publishers deserve the same scrutiny as AAA studios. https://criticalmovespodcast.com/listen This episode provides an honest assessment of Menace’s strengths and significant concerns, with hosts who genuinely enjoyed the tactical combat nevertheless questioning whether Overhype Studios and Hooded Horse are exploiting community goodwill to obscure an incomplete early access release. The conversation dissects the demo’s steep learning curve without tutorials, complex action point systems managing deployment, suppression, and cover mechanics, and extensive squad customization that paradoxically lacks meaningful specialization forcing strategic choices. The hosts explore comparisons to Battle Brothers, debate whether overwhelming information...
WE ARE CRITICAL MOVES
A Strategy Gaming Podcast
About Critical Moves
Critical Moves is a strategy games podcast that takes RTS, 4X, and tactics seriously. Most gaming podcasts treat strategy games as an afterthought. We don’t. Every week we cover real-time strategy, turn-based tactics, 4X empire builders, indie experiments, and overlooked classics with long-form analysis and no wasted time.
This isn’t quick reviews or recycled talking points. It’s sharp criticism and honest discussion about strategy game design. If a game is shallow or broken, we’ll say so. If it does something clever, we’ll explain why it works. We talk to developers without the marketing filter, getting into the mechanics and design choices that actually shape the games.
If you want a RTS podcast, a 4X podcast, or a place for smarter conversations about tactics and strategy gaming, this is it. Critical Moves is made for players who think about systems, mechanics, and design—not just surface impressions.
New episodes every Friday.
LATEST EPISODE
Critical Moves Podcast Trailer
AL
CRITICAL MOVES FOUNDER

NUNO
CRITICAL MOVES FOUNDER

JOSEPH
CRITICAL MOVES HOST

TIMOTHY
CRITICAL MOVES HOST

ADAM
CRITICAL MOVES HOST

JACK
CRITICAL MOVES HOST / ASSISTANT EDITOR












