Episode 1: Strategy Game Remasters – Nostalgia or Cash Grab?

This has been a journey. After three months of planning, recording, and learning the ropes, we’re proud to finally launch Critical Moves. There’s a lot of work behind this, and the entire team has put in the hours to make it happen. Every bit of effort has been worth it, and we couldn’t be happier with the result.

So if you’re a strategy game fan, dive in – give it a listen, subscribe, and let us know what you think. Join the conversation, throw in your perspectives, and get involved. This podcast is as much for you as it is for us.

Strategy Game Remasters: Are They Worth It?

Overview: The debut episode of Critical Moves Podcast takes a deep dive into the world of strategy game remasters, exploring their impact on the genre. Hosts Nuno, Al, Tim, and Joe bring their diverse perspectives to the table, discussing whether remasters are a way to keep classic titles alive or just an easy cash grab for publishers. The conversation explores the emotional nostalgia behind these games, the balance between faithful recreation and meaningful improvements, and whether remasters are preventing true innovation in strategy gaming.

The episode kicks off with a bold stance from Al, who outright dismisses most remasters as lazy attempts at monetizing nostalgia. However, Joe and Nuno counter with examples of well-executed remasters, such as Command & Conquer Remastered and Age of Empires II: Definitive Edition, which successfully preserved the spirit of the original while making quality-of-life improvements. Tim raises the issue of community-driven projects like OpenRA that often surpass official remasters in functionality and updates, raising the question of whether major studios are simply capitalizing on work already done by passionate fans.

A key debate in the episode centers on the difference between a remaster and a remake. Nuno argues that true remasters should update graphics, UI, and controls while preserving the core experience, whereas remakes take more liberties in redesigning gameplay. Pharaoh: A New Era serves as a divisive example, with its cartoony redesign alienating some fans. The hosts also highlight Age of Mythology Retold as a case where modern improvements were generally well-received, despite some concerns over its updated art style.

The discussion shifts to strategy games that deserve a remaster. Joe advocates for Battle for Middle-Earth, envisioning a modern version of Helm’s Deep with current-gen graphics. Al passionately defends Dawn of War, arguing that the first game’s mix of classic RTS and squad-based mechanics deserves a revival. Tim calls for a remaster of Total Annihilation: Kingdoms, emphasizing its unique setting and overlooked potential. Meanwhile, Nuno reminisces about World War II: Frontline Command, a long-forgotten title that captured the transition between Age of Empires and Company of Heroes but is now nearly unplayable due to compatibility issues.

One of the most heated points of debate revolves around whether remasters harm the industry by stifling innovation. Al takes the stance that remasters encourage laziness, allowing companies to profit from nostalgia instead of investing in fresh ideas. Nuno, however, argues that successful remasters have helped prove the market for RTS games, paving the way for new titles like DORF and Tempest Rising. The hosts also touch on infamous failures, such as Warcraft III: Reforged, which alienated its player base by removing beloved multiplayer features while failing to deliver meaningful improvements.

The episode wraps up with a lighthearted moment as Nuno, who had delayed the recording due to a gym session, faces playful banter about not being shirtless on the call. The hosts sign off by teasing the next episode, which will focus on the RTS Renaissance and the resurgence of new strategy games in recent years.

Why Listen? If you love strategy games and have ever debated whether remasters are worth your time and money, this episode is a must-listen. The hosts offer a balanced discussion that touches on both the best and worst examples in the genre, providing insights into how remasters influence the future of strategy gaming. Whether you’re a purist who wants classic titles untouched or a fan of modern quality-of-life improvements, this episode delivers strong opinions, deep industry knowledge, and a fair share of nostalgic reminiscing.

Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music, or search your alternative preferred podcast provider.

Ahh, we’re on YouTube too!