Episode 20: Single Player vs Multiplayer in Strategy Games: What Matters Most?

In episode 20 of Critical Moves, Al, Nuno, and Tim dive into the long-standing debate: is single-player or multiplayer more important in strategy games? The discussion covers everything from commercial success, player preferences, and game longevity to the role of toxicity in online communities.

Single Player: The Commercial Powerhouse?

Al and Nuno argue that single-player experiences remain the backbone of strategy gaming. Data suggests that a majority of players – estimated at over 80% – prefer single-player content, and casual gamers, in particular, tend to avoid competitive multiplayer environments. Historically, even games that became multiplayer hits (like Supreme Commander) got in front of players through strong single-player campaigns first.

Paradox Interactive’s internal data reinforces this, showing that most players stick to single-player modes in grand strategy titles like Hearts of Iron IV and Europa Universalis IV. The panel agrees that single-player campaigns are a major factor in a game’s initial sales, even if multiplayer keeps certain titles alive in the long run.

Multiplayer: Longevity and Player-Driven Content

Tim champions multiplayer as the key to keeping games alive. Unlike single-player content, which requires constant developer resources for scripted missions and AI, multiplayer thrives on player interaction. Games like Beyond All Reason and Company of Heroes have sustained communities for years because of their competitive and cooperative modes.

Nuno pushes back, pointing out that he prefers strategy games for relaxation rather than competition. He argues that multiplayer often demands optimal play, which can make it unappealing for players who just want to experiment with different strategies without feeling pressured.

The group also discusses whether strategy games will ever have a breakout multiplayer success like Call of Duty or League of Legends. While Starcraft was a significant step in that direction, the genre has yet to produce a dominant, enduring multiplayer game at the same level.

The Toxicity Barrier

One of the most divisive parts of the discussion was whether toxicity in multiplayer communities prevents strategy games from growing. Al raises concerns that many single-player gamers avoid multiplayer because of the reputation for toxic behavior. He suggests that new players entering a long-established community often face negativity, discouraging them from sticking around.

Tim, as part of the Beyond All Reason moderation team, explains the balance between keeping an engaged player base and maintaining a welcoming environment. He argues that unchecked toxicity drives away silent majorities of players who might otherwise stay. Nuno, on the other hand, takes a more old-school stance, seeing trash talk as just part of gaming culture.

Despite the disagreement, they all acknowledge that competitive multiplayer games naturally bring out ego-driven conflict, which can be a turn-off for those who just want a casual experience.

Can Strategy Games Have the Best of Both Worlds?

The episode closes with a discussion on whether developers can successfully balance both single-player and multiplayer. Games like Starcraft and Company of Heroes have managed to do both, but the team agrees that this is rare. Al points out that indie developers, who are now carrying the RTS genre forward, often have to pick one or the other due to limited resources.

With Sanctuary: Shattered Sun focusing first on releasing a single-player demo before releasing only with confirmed multiplayer, the panel sees this as a likely model moving forward – games need single-player to sell, but multiplayer for long-term engagement.

Final Thoughts

While single-player remains the dominant mode for strategy games, multiplayer provides the longevity that keeps communities alive. The divide largely comes down to personal preference. Some players enjoy the challenge and social aspects of multiplayer, while others just want a stress-free experience.

Are multiplayer games too toxic? Do strategy games need a strong single-player campaign to succeed? Join the discussion! Head over to CriticalMovesPodcast.com or join us on Discord to share your thoughts.

Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music, or search your alternative preferred podcast provider.

Ahh, we’re on YouTube too!