The strategy gaming genre has long been associated with complexity, deep decision-making, and lengthy learning curves. But does it have to be that way? In this episode of the Critical Moves Podcast, Al, Nuno, and Joe tackle a common misconception: that strategy games are too difficult for new players. The discussion covers accessible entry points into the genre, the increasing complexity of modern strategy games, and whether simplifying gameplay makes a game better or worse. The episode also touches on the evolving appeal of strategy games to younger generations, the impact of microtransactions, and why some of the best beginner-friendly strategy games are still classics from decades past.
Why Strategy Games Have a Reputation for Complexity
One of the key points raised in the episode is how strategy games have developed over the years. Joe argues that many strategy games, particularly grand strategy titles like those from Paradox Interactive, can be overwhelming to newcomers due to their reliance on deep systems and the expectation that players will watch YouTube tutorials to understand the mechanics. Games like Dwarf Fortress, which once had a notoriously difficult learning curve, became far more accessible when the developer added a proper tutorial.
Al reflects on his own experience getting into real-time strategy (RTS) games with Command & Conquer: Red Alert, which was far simpler than many modern RTS titles. He raises an important question: are developers making strategy games unnecessarily complex? While greater processing power allows for more depth, it also risks alienating potential new players.
How Can Strategy Games Appeal to a New Generation?
A major concern for the hosts is how strategy games can remain relevant in a gaming landscape dominated by fast-paced, instant gratification titles like Call of Duty and Grand Theft Auto. Joe suggests that many companies have turned to microtransactions to attract younger players, an approach that is widely disliked by the strategy gaming community. Al brings up an example from Sanctuary: Shattered Sun, where developers are considering microtransactions purely for cosmetic items to fund server costs, rather than implementing pay-to-win mechanics. The hosts agree that while accessibility is key, strategy games should never compromise their core depth in favor of monetization.
The Best Strategy Games for Beginners
The discussion ultimately lands on recommendations for strategy games that are both fun and approachable for newcomers. Al champions Command & Conquer: Remastered Collection as the perfect RTS for new players, offering streamlined gameplay, a fantastic campaign, and modern quality-of-life improvements. Joe suggests Civilization V and Civilization VI due to their structured tutorials, gradual learning curves, and deep but intuitive mechanics.
Nuno brings up Battle Academy 2 as a great introduction to war games, avoiding the complexities of traditional hex-based strategy games while still maintaining tactical depth. Other recommendations include Age of Empires II: Definitive Edition, which remains one of the best RTS games of all time, and XCOM: Enemy Unknown (2012), which provides a modernized take on turn-based tactics with an excellent tutorial system.
The conversation also takes a surprising turn with Al proposing Worms (1995) as an entry point into strategy gaming. While unconventional, the hosts agree that Worms teaches key strategic concepts in a lighthearted and accessible way. The discussion also touches on mobile games like Battle of Polytopia and Boom Beach, which have introduced a younger audience to strategic thinking without the traditional complexity of the genre.
Finding the Right Balance Between Simplicity and Depth
The episode closes with a reflection on how strategy games can be made accessible without sacrificing the elements that make them compelling. Nuno argues that while some simplifications can make a game more approachable, completely stripping away depth results in a lackluster experience. Al counters with the importance of modernizing UI and controls to make older games more intuitive, using Company of Heroes as an example of a game that could benefit from updated control schemes.
Ultimately, the hosts agree that the best way to introduce new players to strategy gaming is to find a balance between challenge and accessibility. Whether it’s through classic titles like Age of Empires II or innovative modern games like Battle Aces, there is no shortage of great strategy games for newcomers.
Why You Should Listen to This Episode
If you’ve ever struggled to get into strategy gaming or know someone who has, this episode is a must-listen. The discussion is insightful, humorous, and packed with valuable recommendations. Whether you’re looking for an RTS, turn-based tactics, or even a mobile game that serves as a gateway into the genre, the Critical Moves team has you covered.
From debates on accessibility to an unexpected deep dive into the legacy of Worms, this episode is a perfect example of why strategy gaming remains a vibrant and evolving genre. Tune in for a mix of nostalgia, expert insights, and, of course, some classic Critical Moves banter.
Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music, or search your alternative preferred podcast provider.
Ahh, we’re on YouTube too!
Discover more from Critical Moves Podcast
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.