Episode 10. The Power of Storytelling in Strategy Games – Do Stories Matter in Strategy Gaming?

Strategy games have long been known for their deep mechanics and tactical gameplay, but what role does storytelling play in this genre? In this episode of Critical Moves, we dive into the impact of narrative in strategy games and whether a strong story enhances or distracts from the experience. Al, Nuno, and Timothy discuss their earliest memories of being captivated by a strategy game’s story and debate how storytelling has evolved over the years.

The conversation begins with early experiences, touching on StarCraft, Warcraft III, and Age of Mythology. These classic RTS titles were known for their strong single-player campaigns, complete with cinematic cutscenes and immersive mission structures. But does that style of storytelling still exist in modern strategy games? The hosts argue that while traditional campaigns still hold a place in the genre, many newer games have moved toward emergent storytelling – where the player’s decisions shape the narrative rather than a fixed, linear story.

A key point of discussion is how strategy games, particularly grand strategy and sandbox titles like Crusader Kings and Stellaris, allow players to craft their own stories. Unlike linear campaigns where players follow a pre-written narrative, these games let players dictate the course of history through their actions, leading to unique and often unpredictable experiences. Nuno highlights how, growing up in Portugal, language barriers prevented him from fully engaging with game narratives until he learned English. This raises an interesting question – does story really matter if the core gameplay is strong enough to stand on its own?

The episode also explores the relationship between mechanics and storytelling. Some strategy games use narrative as a mere framework for missions, while others deeply integrate it into the gameplay. XCOM and Terra Invicta are examples where characters matter, and player choices have lasting consequences, making the stakes feel more real. Meanwhile, Dawn of War and Battlefleet Gothic: Armada demonstrate how established lore can enhance immersion, offering players a direct connection to beloved franchises like Warhammer 40K.

One of the biggest questions raised is whether the lack of compelling storytelling is why strategy games remain a niche genre compared to RPGs and action games. While some players enjoy the raw tactical challenge, the hosts argue that story-driven games tend to have wider appeal. The discussion turns to the commercial side of game development—do companies undervalue storytelling in strategy games because they assume players only care about mechanics? With the resurgence of city-builders, turn-based tactics, and grand strategy games, is the industry missing an opportunity by not investing more in rich narratives?

The episode wraps up with thoughts on the balance between story and gameplay. While some strategy games thrive on emergent narratives and sandbox freedom, others benefit from structured campaigns that provide direction and context. The hosts acknowledge that great storytelling can elevate a strategy game but also recognize that forced or underdeveloped narratives can detract from the experience.

For strategy gaming fans who appreciate both tactical depth and immersive storytelling, this episode is a must-listen. Whether you’re nostalgic for the golden era of RTS campaigns or prefer the open-ended narratives of grand strategy titles, Critical Moves explores the evolving relationship between gameplay and story in the strategy genre.

Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music, or search your alternative preferred podcast provider.

Ahh, we’re on YouTube too!