Can a Strategy Game Work Without a Story? (Ep.39)

Strategy games face a fundamental question that developers can’t afford to ignore: does your game need a story? The answer isn’t as simple as you might expect, and the financial stakes are higher than most realize.

The Economics of Narrative Investment

Creating compelling narratives costs serious money. Full voice acting, pre-rendered cutscenes, historical research, location rights. These expenses can push a game from indie to AAA territory based on story investment alone. Miss the mark on narrative quality, and your game gets immediately categorized as lower-tier regardless of gameplay mechanics.

This creates a harsh reality: if you skimp on story production values, critics and players will notice. The gaming press judges narrative-driven games by cinematic standards now. Fail to meet those expectations, and you’re branded as budget-tier before players even see your core mechanics.

Two Paths Forward: Scripted vs Emergent

Strategy games essentially have two narrative approaches. Scripted storytelling gives you complete control—think Warcraft 3’s legendary campaign or the atmospheric world-building in Heroes of Might and Magic. You craft every moment, every character arc, every emotional beat.

Emergent storytelling takes the opposite route. Games like Stellaris and Crusader Kings hand players tools and let them build their own stories through gameplay systems. Your ruler’s traits combine with random events and diplomatic choices to create unique narratives each playthrough.

Both approaches work, but they serve different audiences and require different investments.

The Single Player Reality Check

Here’s the commercial truth most multiplayer-focused developers miss: roughly 80% of strategy game players prefer single-player experiences. They want campaigns. They want progression. They don’t want to get demolished by some teenager from South Korea in their first online match.

This reality hit the developers of Sanctuary: Shattered Sun hard. Originally planned as a spiritual successor to Supreme Commander focused on multiplayer, they’ve completely pivoted. Their upcoming demo will be a single-player mission because they recognized this fundamental market truth.

The Localization Factor

Translation matters more than most Western developers realize. In Poland, games didn’t become culturally significant until companies started translating them properly. Heroes of Might and Magic 3 became legendary there partly because it was one of the first major strategy games to receive quality Polish translation.

Poor or missing translations create barriers that prevent games from achieving broad cultural impact. When players can’t understand the story, they click through dialogue and miss the entire narrative experience.

The Tropes Problem

Modern strategy game narratives often feel derivative. Tempest Rising, despite being an excellent game, follows the familiar Command & Conquer template almost beat-for-beat: two factions fighting, mysterious third faction appears, chaos ensues. It’s competent but predictable.

This raises uncomfortable questions about originality. Are there truly new stories left to tell, or are we just recombining existing elements in slightly different ways? Most narratives today borrow heavily from established mythologies and previous games, mixing elements until something feels fresh enough to pass as original.

The Beyond All Reason Contradiction

Beyond All Reason presents an interesting case study. Built directly on Total Annihilation’s foundation – same units, same factions, same basic setup – but completely lacks narrative content. This seems puzzling since Total Annihilation had full campaigns for both the ARM and Core factions.

The community has proposed campaign ideas multiple times, but nothing materializes. Part of this stems from the community-driven development model, but it also reflects a design philosophy that prioritized gameplay mechanics over narrative coherence. The result is a technically superior game that feels narratively hollow compared to its inspiration.

When Stories Aren’t Essential

Some games succeed without traditional narratives. Stronghold Crusader offered 60+ missions that were essentially disconnected challenges. No overarching plot, just scenarios with basic setup text. Players still found reasons to engage because the individual mission premises provided enough context.

This suggests that full narrative campaigns aren’t always necessary. Sometimes players just need a framework—a reason to fight, even if that reason doesn’t connect to a larger story arc.

The Atmospheric Alternative

Heroes of Might and Magic demonstrates another approach: prioritize world-building over plot. The individual campaign missions were repetitive and forgettable, but the Might and Magic universe felt rich and lived-in. Players created their own stories within established lore, making scenario play feel meaningful even without scripted narratives.

This middle ground—strong world-building with loose narrative structure—might be more viable for smaller developers than attempting full cinematic campaigns.

The Paradox of Choice

Strategy games without any narrative element create a different problem: they feel incomplete. Games need either emergent narrative systems or scripted campaigns. Without one or the other, there’s simply a hole in the product that players notice immediately.

This explains why survival-focused games often struggle commercially despite solid mechanics. Players want context for their actions, some sense of purpose beyond pure optimization puzzles.

The Cost-Benefit Analysis

The harsh reality is that narrative investment significantly impacts a game’s commercial potential. Skip the story entirely, and you alienate the majority of strategy game players. Invest heavily in narrative but execute poorly, and you’ve wasted resources while still disappointing your audience.

The safest middle ground might be focusing on emergent storytelling systems that generate narrative moments through gameplay rather than expensive pre-scripted content. Players often feel more connected to stories they help create than ones imposed on them.

Strategy games live or die on whether they give players reasons to care about their actions. That reason can come from elaborate cutscenes or emergent gameplay moments, but it has to come from somewhere. The developers who understand this survive. The ones who don’t become cautionary tales about missing the point entirely.

Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music, or search your alternative preferred podcast provider.

Ahh, we’re on YouTube too!